You Should Have Left (2020) Movie Review

  • Home
  • You Should Have Left

You Should Have Left: A Disorienting Horror Experience

Mar 26, 2025 4 min read You Should Have Left: A Disorienting Horror Experience backdrop image

Welcome to my movie review of You Should Have Left, the 2020 film directed by David Koepp. This horror, mystery, and thriller flick offers a wild, psychological ride with actors Kevin Bacon and Amanda Seyfried leading the charge. Is it one of the best horror movies of the year, or does it fall flatter than a ghost in daylight? Let's dive into this movie breakdown and find out!

So here's the setup: we've got a former banker, his actress wife, and their totally adorable daughter heading to the Welsh countryside for some good ol’ rest and relaxation. Or so they think—because, surprise! The house they've rented is a real doozy. Things get creepy fast as odd occurrences pile up, and they start questioning reality. The themes are all about isolation, paranoia, and the haunted labyrinth of one’s mind. The unique twist? The house itself is a character, adding layers to the mystery. Imagine if HGTV did a crossover with 'The Shining'—now that’s some quality reality television!

The acting power couple of Kevin Bacon and Amanda Seyfried deliver performances with a lingering intensity. Bacon’s portrayal of a man unraveling is particularly strong; he's like a modern-day Job, fighting against forces he can’t explain. Seyfried matches him well, bringing depth to the role of a wife who’s understandably skeptical of the strange happenings. Avery Tiiu Essex, playing the daughter, offers an innocence that contrasts sharply with the eerie plot. David Koepp certainly knows his way around a thriller, adding suspenseful beats with precision, while the screenplay also penned by Koepp, channels existential dread. The cinematography captures the stark and beautiful landscape of Wales—even though you'll be too tense to appreciate it fully.

If you're a fan of mind-bending thrillers like 'Get Out' or 'The Others', You Should Have Left fits neatly into that niche of eerie psychological horror. It toys with your perceptions and keeps you guessing. The difference here is the wildly unpredictable structure of the narrative—like a horror Rubik's cube that’s missing a few squares. While other movies might offer jump scares, this one provides creeping under-the-skin discomfort. It doesn’t quite reach the cinematic heights of its peers due to its sometimes disjointed script, but hey, it's certainly intriguing!

As someone who’s danced with the horror genre through highs and lows, I'll say this: if you love tales of hauntings and psychological quandaries, this movie is a must-watch. But manage those expectations—it's an acquired taste. For those who revel in dissecting a cinematic masterpiece and enjoy a good film critique, this one will give you plenty to chew on (and critters to spook about in the night). In a nutshell, You Should Have Left might not be everyone's cup of haunted tea, but it leaves a memorable chill! So grab your cozy blanket, maybe a pet to cling to, and let the goosebumps commence!