Troy (2004) Movie Review

Epic Battles and Star Power: Troy Movie Review

Mar 09, 2025 4 min read Epic Battles and Star Power: Troy Movie Review backdrop image

In this movie review of Troy, a film directed by Wolfgang Petersen, we plunge into a world of sword-wielding warriors, ancient rivalries, and larger-than-life personalities. Categorized under Action, Adventure, and Drama, this cinematic adaptation of Homer's epic tale promises a visual spectacle that aims to capture the timeless struggle for glory and survival. But does it hit all the right notes? Let's dive in and find out!

The plot of Troy follows the legendary assault on Troy, orchestrated by the united Greek forces, as described in Homer’s iconic Iliad. The film attempts to condense a sweeping narrative into a digestible two-and-a-half-hour experience. And while it dips its toes in themes of love, honor, and betrayal, one can argue it’s the heart-pounding intensity of battle scenes that truly steals the show. The sprawling beaches and grand Trojan walls provide a fitting backdrop for this ancient showdown. What stands out most, perhaps, is the human conflict against the looming war’s canvas—where heroes aren't always as noble as we'd expect. Ever wonder what Brad Pitt with a man bun looked like era-specific armor? Here’s your chance!

Let’s talk star power—Julian Glover, Brian Cox, Nathan Jones, Adoni Maropis, and Jacob Smith all bring their A-game. But it’s Brad Pitt’s portrayal of Achilles that packs a punch, both literally and figuratively. He balances brawn with a contemplative touch, adding depth to a character often considered an enigma. Then there's Eric Bana, exuding noble gravitas as Hector, who you can't help but root for. The film’s cinematography, helmed by Roger Pratt, delivers sweeping vistas and intense close-ups that amplify the drama with every sword clash. Wolfgang Petersen directs with a keen eye for grandiosity, but occasionally the screenplay by David Benioff stumbles with clichés and predictable dialogue. It certainly feels like Petersen was more interested in the spectacle than nuance. Does it detract from the overall experience? Maybe a bit.

How does Troy measure up to its genre counterparts? Think of it as a sibling to films like 300 or Gladiator, though it doesn’t quite reach the emotional depth of Ridley Scott’s work or the visual stylings of Zack Snyder. It’s like the middle child of epic cinema—not quite as groundbreaking, but reliable for a good old-fashioned watch. There are elements, especially in some CGI-heavy sequences, that feel a tad dated now, akin to early 2000s' experimentation with digital effects. Yet, it still delivers enough sword-and-sandal vibes to keep fans of historical epics entertained.

So, should Troy be on your watch list? If you're a fan of Action and Adventure, or if Drama with a side of Brad Pitt’s Achilles piques your interest, this film is undoubtedly a must-watch. While it may not be the cinematic masterpiece some hoped for, it stands as a significant entry in the pantheon of historical films. Ready your chariots and let this ancient tale sweep you away.