The Proposal (2009) Movie Review

The Proposal Movie Review: Love Redefined

Apr 04, 2025 4 min read The Proposal Movie Review: Love Redefined backdrop image

The Proposal, directed by Anne Fletcher, is the kind of movie that sneaks up on you, delivering charming moments wrapped in a package of comedy, drama, and romance. Released in 2009, this film stars the ever-talented Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds, who engage in an offbeat relationship that really is something to write home about. Tackling themes like love, ambition, and identity—this movie review will unpack all the delightful and, perhaps, not-so-delightful aspects of this rom-com gem.

Now, picture this: A high-powered New York editor, Margaret—played by Bullock—finds herself in a bit of a pickle when her visa issues threaten her career. Who knew deportation could lead to such hijinks? Margaret hatches a ludicrous plan with her assistant, Andrew (Reynolds), to wed and secure her green card. It’s all going smoothly—or not—until they fly over to Andrew's hometown in Alaska. Here, amidst majestic landscapes and quirky townsfolk (hello, Betty White stealing scenes left and right), Margaret discovers more than she bargained for. She starts off as the typical high-strung career woman but gradually evolves as Andrew’s warm and loving family—the Steenburgen and Nelson duo—circles her with affection and plenty of fish-out-of-water moments.

Let’s talk about the juiciness of it all—the acting, direction, and writing. Sandra Bullock and Ryan Reynolds have chemistry that emanates through the screen like hot cocoa on a cold day. It's sweet and a little bit spicy. Bullock’s comedic timing bounces off Reynolds’ charm-drenched delivery, creating a dynamic that elevates the perhaps predictable storyline into an engaging experience. While Anne Fletcher’s direction keeps the narrative flowing smoothly, Peter Chiarelli’s screenplay provides enough zingers and sentimental beats to keep your interest piqued. Sure, some bits are a tad formulaic, but hey, isn’t that part of the comfort we seek in rom-coms?

Comparatively speaking, if you’re into movies like 10 Things I Hate About You or The Wedding Planner, 'The Proposal' fits snugly in the same vein. Unlike the wild craziness of a Bridesmaids, the movie's humor is grounded yet delightful—as if welcoming you into the quirky family Cornetts’ living room for stories and shenanigans. Additionally, echoes of Notting Hill and While You Were Sleeping can be felt in its romantic aspirations, focusing on character growth and rediscovery amid humorous scenarios.

So, should you pop some popcorn and dive into this flick? Well, if gripping drama or horror isn’t your cup of tea, then why not? If you love romance-comedies, take the plunge—like you’re leaping into the arms of a lumberjack lover in a snowy Alaskan setting. The film might not be a cinematic masterpiece or redefine the genre, but it’s got just enough charm, laughs, and heart to make it a must-watch film for fans of love stories that leave you with a smile. It’s a little formulaic, a little predictable, but isn’t that what we secretly crave?